Surfshark vs Private Internet Access — Full Comparison 2026

Speed Comparison

In our speed tests, Surfshark achieved download speeds of 880 Mbps while Private Internet Access reached 810 Mbps. Both VPNs were tested on a 1 Gbps connection from multiple locations. Surfshark had the edge in raw throughput, though both services deliver speeds that are more than adequate for streaming, gaming, and everyday browsing.

Latency is equally important, especially for gaming and video calls. Surfshark averaged 32ms while Private Internet Access came in at 38ms. Lower latency means more responsive connections, which matters for real-time applications.

Security & Privacy

Both Surfshark and Private Internet Access offer strong security foundations with AES-256 encryption and no-logs policies. Surfshark supports WireGuard, OpenVPN, IKEv2, while Private Internet Access offers WireGuard, OpenVPN. Both include essential security features like kill switches and DNS leak protection.

Where they differ is in the extras. Surfshark offers features like Unlimited Devices, CleanWeb Ad Blocker, MultiHop, while Private Internet Access counters with Open-Source Apps, MACE Ad Blocker, Port Forwarding. These additional features can be the deciding factor depending on your specific needs.

Streaming

Streaming capability is a major differentiator between VPNs. Surfshark successfully unblocked Netflix, Disney+, Hulu, BBC iPlayer, Amazon Prime, HBO Max in our testing. Private Internet Access worked with Netflix, Disney+, Hulu, Amazon Prime, HBO Max. Both are solid choices for streaming, though Surfshark was slightly more consistent across platforms.

Pricing & Value

Surfshark starts at $2.19/mo on the 2-year plan ($15.45/mo monthly), while Private Internet Access costs $2.03/mo for 2 years ($11.99/mo monthly). Both offer 30-day money-back guarantees, so you can try either risk-free.

Our Verdict

Surfshark wins with unlimited devices, better speeds, and a more modern interface. PIA counters with open-source apps, more server locations, and proven no-logs credentials in court.

Ultimately, both Surfshark and Private Internet Access are excellent VPN services. Your choice should depend on which features matter most to you. If speed and server coverage are priorities, check the numbers above. If price is the deciding factor, compare the long-term plan costs. Either way, you're getting a quality VPN.